A Texas man bought a $349,900 home and fell $4,176 behind; foreclosure warnings went to an address where mail could not be delivered, his home sold for $166,983, and an appeals court upheld $116,998 in damages


A Texas man bought a $349,900 home and fell $4,176 behind; foreclosure warnings went to an address where mail could not be delivered, his home sold for $166,983, and an appeals court upheld $116,998 in damages
The Texas Fourteenth Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s judgment on November 17.

A Texas appeals court has upheld a $116,998 damages award to a homeowner whose property was foreclosed on without proper notice after he fell behind on loan payments by just $4,176. The court ruled that the lender violated state law by sending foreclosure notices to a business address instead of the man’s residential address, where he actually lived.The Texas Fourteenth Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s judgment on November 17, ruling that the foreclosure proceedings were defective because the homeowner never received proper notice of the default or the sale.

Home sold for $166,983 despite being bought for $349,900

The dispute involved Keith Boyer, who sold a property in Harris County, Texas, to Ryan Heasley for $349,900. The property had two separate addresses: 822 Havard, where the residential house was located, and 25523 Helms, which was used for a commercial business.After purchasing the property, Heasley fell behind on his loan payments, accumulating dues of $4,176.60.Boyer’s attorney sent a notice of default and intent to accelerate the loan to the Helms address. However, the letter was returned because it could not be delivered. A second notice, informing Heasley of the loan acceleration and foreclosure sale, was also sent to the same address and returned unclaimed.Despite both notices being returned, Boyer did not send them to the Havard address, where Heasley lived and received his mail.The property subsequently went into foreclosure and was sold for $166,983, less than half the original purchase price. Heasley said he only learned about the sale after letters from the new buyers were posted on his front door.The buyers told him that he would have to leave the property or lease or purchase it back from them.

Court says foreclosure notices must reach homeowner’s residence

Heasley subsequently filed a wrongful foreclosure lawsuit against Boyer. A trial court awarded him $116,997.92 in damages, prompting Boyer to challenge the decision before the appeals court.Boyer argued that he had fulfilled his legal obligation by sending certified notices to the Helms address, which was listed as the property’s mailing address in the deed of trust.However, the appeals court rejected the argument, pointing to the Texas Property Code’s distinction between a debtor’s residential property and commercial or investment property.Under Texas law, when a property being foreclosed is the debtor’s residence, the notice must be sent to the person’s residential address unless the debtor has formally provided a written change of address.The court noted that the Helms address was used for the commercial business and there was no evidence that anyone had lived there. Both Boyer and Heasley had identified the Havard address as the residential property.It also ruled that listing the Helms address as a mailing address in property documents did not amount to a formal written change of address for foreclosure notices.The judges stressed that foreclosure proceedings require strict compliance with legal notice requirements, particularly when a person’s home is at stake.

Appeals court finds inadequate notice linked to low sale price

The court also rejected Boyer’s argument that there was insufficient evidence connecting the failure to provide proper notice with the property’s low foreclosure sale price.It noted that the property had been appraised at $300,000 in 2015, while Heasley had purchased it for $349,900. Yet, less than three years later, it was sold at foreclosure for around $166,983.The homeowner also testified that the foreclosure buyers later offered to sell the property back to him for $475,000. A subsequent settlement allowed him to repurchase it for $225,000.The appeals court said the evidence supported the conclusion that the defective notice had contributed to the property being sold at a significantly lower price.It ultimately rejected both grounds raised in Boyer’s appeal and affirmed the trial court’s judgment awarding Heasley $116,997.92.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *