Question
Speaking about the economy, Kevin Warsh did say that there could be some ramifications for monetary policy when it comes to the artificial intelligence (AI) trade. Just trying to figure out what your thoughts on that are. Have you put any numbers to it, and what are your expectations beyond the December 25-basis-point rate hike, which is pretty much being factored in by the market?
Answer:
So, the whole technology investment story has been hugely impactful on the US economy. You look at the level of capital investment going into chips and semiconductors and the building of data centers. On some measures, it’s equivalent to nearly a third of economic activity. But we’ve got to remember that this requires huge imports from the likes of Korea and Taiwan, and those have effectively offset much of that capital expenditure because so much money has been spent on the chips. The hoarding of these chips has actually been a huge drag. So, on a net basis right now, it’s actually offsetting itself. The imports are subtracting the same amount as the actual capex spending is contributing. That will obviously change and shift over time. But I guess, in terms of what Kevin Warsh is thinking about the impact on monetary policy, it’s more of a longer-term story. Not only is it about how much it’s boosting growth right now, but what ramifications does it have for the jobs market? What ramifications does it have for the trend rate of growth in America? And, of course, what does it mean for inflation as well? There’s still a huge amount of uncertainty. All we know from the Fed is that it’s pretty clear we’re probably going to get a December rate rise, but thereafter it is quite uncertain because, as you mentioned earlier, we’ve seen some really big downward moves in commodity prices that can really help to dampen inflationary pressures next year.
Question
Taking everything into account, what are you factoring in from the Fed? A 25-basis-point hike in December?
Answer:
Yes, certainly 25 basis points. And after that, we’re not looking for anything further. A key reason for that is that energy prices are really coming down aggressively now. Gasoline prices have fallen from $4.50 a gallon in the United States to $3.75 a gallon already. And it’s not just because oil prices are falling. Tanker rates—the cost of shipping crude—have plummeted as well. They’ve fallen by more than a third, and these factors are really helping. Add to that the fact that precious metals are down significantly.
Question
Do you think it is possible that they do not hike even in December? Could they just give a hawkish tone and then wait for further data to confirm whether another hike is needed?
Answer:
I think they will hike in December. I think that’s pretty clear. We’ve had almost universal commentary from the Fed that they’re looking towards that hike, and we had the minutes of the FOMC meeting as well in the last 24 hours. Again, that indicated it was more of a delay rather than a re-evaluation of the need for rate hikes. So certainly, I think December is a done deal.
Question
If I’m not mistaken, earlier you had mentioned, a few months ago, that you’re expecting crude oil prices to head back towards the $80-$90 per barrel range. You had told us that in an earlier interview, and that’s probably going to be the case. We’re already at around the $91-per-barrel mark. So how do you see the trends panning out on that front with regard to crude? Do you want to revise those levels?
Answer:
No, I think we’re still pretty happy with the price levels. There has certainly been some demand destruction coming through, but we are starting to see the flow of supply coming through as well. However, we need inventories to be rebuilt on top of that. So, we’re being pulled in a few different directions here. So, in terms of the actual price of crude, we’re looking for that to stay pretty stable in the near term before perhaps drifting lower as we move through the first half of next year. But we’re seeing much more movement right now in tanker rates. We were talking about it costing a million dollars a day to transport some of the crude on these very large crude carriers. That’s really coming down, getting closer to half a million dollars a day, and that really does help as well. So, it’s not just the actual commodity price. We’ve got to remember the shipping costs and, of course, the refining margins as well, as that feeds through into the retail price that we all pay.
Question
Do you have a house view on gold and silver? Because gold has been on a bit of a meltdown as well from its peak, and silver even more so.
Answer:
We have seen these substantial moves lower. I guess right now we’re in an environment where we’re seeing rising interest rates, and that’s really helping to dampen demand for those traditional safe-haven assets. So, we’re seeing it in gold, silver, and Bitcoin as well, as we move into this environment where markets are sensing that interest rates could be higher for longer.
Question
What about the other central banks globally? I recall that in the past you said there are some concerns in Japan, and probably we should be bracing for higher rates there. How are you reading the economic trends globally, particularly in the Japanese economy?
Answer:
Yes, we’re looking for interest rates to rise pretty broadly across economies. Certainly, in the UK, we’re looking for another ECB rate hike in December as well. But certainly, Japan is probably where we are seeing more upside risk at the moment. In general, as mentioned, we see less chance of a prolonged tightening cycle in the US and Europe, but we see a greater chance of actual rate hikes being more significant than the market expects in Japan, largely because we’ve got a pretty strong economy right now. We’re moving from very low levels of interest rates, and we’ve got inflation that is now above target. So, we certainly would expect another couple of rate hikes from the Bank of Japan over the next six months.
Question
Let’s wrap it up then with a view on India because the economy was never a problem. The performance of the economy, despite rising crude prices, wasn’t a problem. We were just hoping for some foreign fund flows to come to India. Given the AI trade, they were diverted towards that, and now that the AI trade is losing momentum, perhaps plateauing and turning jittery, the funds have come back to India, and that’s reflected in the stock market. But what is your call on the Indian economy and whether there could be some sort of respite in inflation because of reduced commodity prices?
Answer:
I think India, like many other countries that import a lot of energy and raw commodities, will benefit from these price moves that we’ve seen over the last two months. In terms of the broader themes, that’s going to relieve a lot of pressure and ease the pressure on the central bank to raise rates aggressively from here. But as you say, we’re seeing the markets reappraise the outlook for AI, to which India was seen as being vulnerable, given the risk of outsourcing flows diminishing. So, this discussion just allows for a bit of a pause, a bit of a re-evaluation, and we are seeing, as you say, something of a correction right now.
