Franklin Templeton Global Chief Executive Officer Jenny Johnson has flagged succession planning risks at some of the world’s largest companies, including Nvidia and Tesla, saying that boards must prepare for the possibility of their chief executives stepping down or becoming unavailable.
Speaking to CNBC-TV18, Johnson questioned Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s management structure, saying she was surprised to learn that he had 60 direct reports and that such a structure raised questions about the company’s succession planning.
“I was surprised to learn that Jensen had 60 direct reports because I don’t think when you have 60 direct reports that you’re actually grooming anyone to be CEO,” Johnson said.
She said nurturing successors was among the most important responsibilities of a chief executive, adding that companies risk creating key-man dependencies when leadership succession is not addressed.
“If you think that you are the only one and you built the company to be the only person and create key-man risk, that is not really doing your job as a CEO,” she said.
From Steve Jobs to Jensen Huang: The succession question
Commenting on the importance of succession planning, Johnson cited Apple’s experience with Steve Jobs, saying the company faced difficulties after he was initially pushed out because there was no successor prepared to take over.
She said Jobs later mentored Tim Cook and helped position him to lead the company. Johnson also pointed to Amazon founder Jeff Bezos, who mentored Andy Jassy before handing over the chief executive role.
“One of the most important responsibilities of a CEO is to be nurturing the successors,” she said.
Johnson added that succession planning was a regular discussion at Franklin Templeton’s board and at the board of a large pharmaceutical company on which she serves.
Also read: Anthropic’s record IPO: Amodei siblings on $900 billion AI bets, safety and what’s next
Elon Musk and the risk of a company built around one person
Johnson also identified Elon Musk as an example of a business leader whose departure could pose a succession challenge for a company.
Speaking on the risks associated with Musk’s leadership at Tesla and SpaceX, she said, “I think there’s probably key-man risk behind somebody like an Elon Musk.”
Acknowledging Musk’s contributions, Johnson said, “He’s phenomenal. I mean, the things that he’s accomplished and continues to accomplish.”
She added that SpaceX was ahead of its competitors in the space sector and that Musk would be difficult to replace.
However, Johnson said the responsibility of preparing for such a possibility rested with both the chief executive and the company’s board.
“He’s still his job and the board’s jobs to be asking themselves if Elon gets hit by a bus, what are we going to do? Who is he mentoring to bring in the system?” she said.
Johnson’s comments come amid broader questions around leadership concentration at companies whose strategies, operations and market valuations are closely associated with their founders or chief executives. She argued that boards must ensure that businesses can continue to operate and execute their strategies even in the absence of their current leaders.
Franklin Templeton CEO Jenny Johnson flags key-man risk at Nvidia, Tesla; questions Jensen Huang’s succession planning
