Moving out of a rental home can be stressful, but for one couple in Ohio, the end of their tenancy turned into an expensive legal battle after their belongings were put outside for strangers to go through. What started as a dispute over a move-out deadline has ended up in an appeals court, which affirmed a decision that the landlords pay thousands of dollars in damages, attorney fees and court costs.
Landlord puts couple’s stuff outside
The case involved Jasmine and Charles Petties, who had lived in a residential property in Stark County, Ohio, since 2015, the Ohio Court of Appeals, Fifth District said. Charles signed a one-year lease initially, but then the lease went to month-to-month.In 2023, landlord Marvin Johnson put the property up for sale and offered Charles the opportunity to purchase it. The couple then began to make other accommodation arrangements when they found they could not afford to buy the home, the online data informs.Charles told Johnson in July 2023 he had found somewhere else and would move in September. But the two sides failed to agree on a mutually acceptable exit date.Johnson gave the couple a three-day notice Sept. 15 telling them to be out by the next day. On September 16 the couple started loading their belongings into a rental truck, with Johnson assisting in the process. The next day it escalated when Johnson told Charles the rest of his belongings would be put outside. The appellate court’s account says the possessions were moved to the curb and members of the public began going through them. Johnson then reached out to Jasmine and asked the couple to come pick up their stuff because people were trying to take it.
Couple sues over damaged property
Jasmine went to the police in April 2024 before she filed a lawsuit. The complaint originally alleged unlawful landlord activity, trespass, negligence, civil conspiracy, and punitive damages. The trial court thereafter allowed an amendment to the complaint adding Charles as a co-plaintiff.Jasmine testified about several damaged or missing items at the bench trial in May 2025. Missing items included a broken treadmill, a damaged entertainment center and a backpack containing an Apple Watch and jewelry. She put the value of the damaged and missing items at a combined $5,790.The magistrate found the landlords were in violation of Ohio’s residential landlord-tenant law and awarded the couple $5,790 in compensatory damages. But the court dismissed their claims for trespassing and punitive damages.
Appeals court rejects landlord’s arguments
The landlords appealed the decision on three grounds: that Charles should not have been added to the lawsuit, that the damages were miscalculated and that the award of attorney fees was wrong. The Ohio Court of Appeals, Fifth District, affirmed the lower court’s judgment in a November 13, 2026 ruling, rejecting all three arguments.The appeals court determined that adding Charles as a plaintiff was permissible because it added no new claims or defendants and did not unfairly prejudice the landlords.It further rejected the challenge to the award of damages, holding that the appellants had not challenged the magistrate’s findings and had not provided a trial transcript necessary for review of their evidentiary arguments.also confirmed 7,223 in
Legal fees and details
The landlords also challenged the award of attorney fees, claiming it was beyond the amount contemplated in the couple’s contingency-fee agreement with their attorney. The appellate court disagreed, finding that Ohio law permits tenants to recover reasonable attorney fees for landlord violations of the statutory protections. A private agreement between the client and the lawyer does not limit the amount that can be recovered from the landlord.The additional amount owed was $7,223, which included $6,700 in attorney fees and $523 in costs awarded by the lower courtAll three of the appellate challenges were rejected, and the judgment in Petties v. Johnson was affirmed. Therefore, the landlords were on the hook for the combined $13,013 in damages, legal fees and costs.Image Courtesy: istock
