The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has warned that a Supreme Court ruling reversing the write-off of bonds issued by troubled lender Yes Bank could undermine bank rescue rules, a court filing reviewed by Reuters showed.
The dispute stems from Yes Bank’s rescue in 2020 when authorities wrote off 84.15 billion rupees worth of additional Tier-1 (AT1) bonds, a type of security designed to absorb losses when banks run into trouble.
In a court filing dated November 13, the RBI said that the apex court’s ruling conflicted with loss-absorption provisions under international Basel banking regulations and that restoring the risky bonds could hurt Yes Bank’s existing depositors.
The arguments were made in a review petition that is not publicly available. The RBI and Yes Bank did not immediately respond to Reuters requests for comment.
Last month, the Supreme Court ruled the write-off illegal over procedural lapses and ordered the bonds restored, but review petitions by the bank and RBI have delayed relief for investors.
The RBI argued that writing down or converting AT1 bonds was inevitable under India’s bank rescue framework and that allowing them to survive a restructuring would defeat their purpose of absorbing losses.
“The effect of the impugned judgment thus defeats the mandatory loss-absorption requirement of AT-1 Bonds and renders the relevant provisions of the Basel III Master Circular otiose,” RBI said.
Basel regulations are a set of internationally accepted standards for banks.
The RBI in the court filing warned that the ruling could have wider implications for India’s bank rescue framework, arguing that regulations and bond terms already required AT1 bonds to be written down, even without an explicit provision in the restructuring plan.
Restoring 84.14 billion rupees ($900.52 million) in liabilities would dilute capital injected by State Bank of India and other rescue investors and weaken depositor protections, the RBI said.
The regulator also rejected the court’s characterisation of it as a “mere bystander” during Yes Bank’s collapse, saying it had repeatedly pushed the lender to raise capital, appointed an additional director and ultimately intervened when the bank became insolvent.
($1 = 93.4350 Indian rupees)
