Former Tata Trusts Trustee Darius Khambata has written to Tata Trusts Vice-Chairmen Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh, questioning their change of stance on the listing of Tata Sons and disputing their claim that Trustees were kept informed of engagement with the Reserve Bank of India (RBI).
The letter, dated November 17, seen by CNBC-TV18, replies to a November 13 letter from the two Vice-Chairmen. Khambata says that letter was addressed to him and sent to the Trusts, but not sent to him. His term as a Trustee of the Sir Dorabji Tata Trust ended on November 9, after he chose not to seek reappointment.
On Tata Sons listing
Khambata says Srinivasan and Singh have still not explained why they changed their minds on listing in April 2026. He says they had backed the anti-listing stand of both Tata Sons and Tata Trusts in March 2024, May 2025 and July 2025.
My grievance is why you repeatedly voted to oppose listing but suddenly did a volte face in April 2026.”DARIUS KHAMBATA, FORMER Trustee, TATA TRUSTS
“My grievance is why you repeatedly voted to oppose listing but suddenly did a volte face in April 2026,” he writes. He adds that he has not called it “a betrayal”, as the Vice-Chairmen have characterised his allegation.
He says the merits of listing should be debated at a Trust meeting, not in letters or the media, and that the two Vice-Chairmen never started that debate.
Khambata also rejects their use of Novo Nordisk as an example. He says the structure of Novo Nordisk is similar to that of Tata Sons today and “is a strong argument against listing!”
On RBI
Khambata disputes the Vice-Chairmen’s claim that Trustees were kept informed about engagement with the RBI.
“I do not recall receiving any feedback after July 2025 on engagement with the RBI,” he writes. He also asks them to relook at the Articles of Association of Tata Sons and the history of their amendment.
He says the person who drafted their letter “obviously did not have the correct facts”.
This comes a day after the RBI wrote to Tata Sons, telling it to comply with the rules for upper-layer NBFCs, “including the requirement of listing by your company.”
In the November 16 letter, the RBI said Tata Sons had not sought guidance on any particular regulation when it wrote to the regulator on October 6. It added that, going by the Tata Sons board’s discussion on listing, the query appeared to be about listing.
Tata Trusts had maintained that the RBI never specifically mentioned listing in its earlier communications.
This comes a day after the RBI wrote to Tata Sons, telling it to comply with the rules for upper-layer NBFCs, “including the requirement of listing by your company.”
In the November 16 letter, the RBI said Tata Sons had not sought guidance on any particular regulation when it wrote to the regulator on October 6. It added that, going by the Tata Sons board’s discussion on listing, the query appeared to be about listing. Tata Trusts had maintained that the RBI never specifically mentioned listing in its earlier communications.
On Chandrasekaran’s third term
Khambata says there is no contradiction in his position on N Chandrasekaran’s third term. He voted for the reappointment in July 2025 based on performance figures he calls “very impressive”. He says his November 2 letter was about how the Tata Sons board acted on September 17, not about Chandrasekaran’s performance.
He denies being silent when uncertainty arose over the third term. He says he wrote to all co-Trustees on March 2, 2026, seeking a meeting after the February 23 board meeting. “No Trustee responded. Was I to hold a meeting by myself?” he writes.
No Trustee responded. Was I to hold a meeting by myself?DARIUS KHAMBATA, FORMER TRUSTEE, TATA TRUSTS
He also asks whether Srinivasan, as a Trust nominee director, told Tata Sons’ Nomination and Remuneration Committee about the July 2025 resolution before it decided on September 3, 2026 to ask Chandrasekaran to continue.
On Mehli Mistry and the Trustee resolution
Khambata says Srinivasan, Singh and Noel Tata did not follow the October 17, 2024 resolution themselves when they voted against Mehli Mistry’s reappointment. “Those who breached it, cannot point fingers!” he writes.
Those who breached it, cannot point fingers!”DARIUS KHAMBATA, FORMER TRUSTEE, TATA TRUSTS
He rejects the claim that he planned to “temporarily oust” Srinivasan as a Trustee. He says he voted to reappoint Srinivasan in October 2025 and on November 11, 2025, when his one vote could have blocked it. He also points out that Singh proposed Bhaskar Bhatt as a Trustee at the same meeting where Khambata proposed Neville Tata.
On the Tata Model
Khambata says control of Tata Sons by Tata Trusts is the essence of the Tata Model, and that this does not affect the tax-exempt status of the Trusts. He says the Vice-Chairmen have misread the Supreme Court’s Tata vs Mistry judgement.
He calls the suggestion that he has not acted independently “patently false”, and says he differed with Noel Tata on several major issues in 2025 and 2026. “It is apparent that because I called out 17th September, I am now subjected to a personal attack,” Khambata writes. He adds he will not respond in kind and welcomes the Vice-Chairmen’s call for a resolution.
