Elon Musk has claimed that Russia would have already won its war against Ukraine if Kyiv had not received access to SpaceX’s Starlink satellite internet network, arguing that the technology has been instrumental in keeping Ukrainian forces connected since Moscow launched its full-scale invasion in February 2022. Speaking at The New York Times’ DealBook Summit on Wednesday, Musk said Starlink was the only communications system Russia had been unable to disable after its invasion destroyed Ukraine’s existing communications infrastructure.“I think it would probably be accurate to say that there is no private individual who has helped Ukraine more than I have,” Musk boasted. “I made sure that Starlink was in Ukraine prepositioned ahead of the Russian invasion.”“And when Russia invaded, they disabled all communications, all cell towers, all fiber cables and every satellite communication system. There was one system they could not disable and that was Starlink.”“If they had not had Starlink, their entire line would have collapsed because they had no communication system and Russia would have won,” he added.The billionaire, who joined the interview remotely, also described his contribution to Ukraine’s defence as extraordinary, claiming that no other private individual had helped the country more than he had.“Even to this present day, Starlink provides the backbone of communications for the Ukrainian military and for Ukraine more broadly,” he said.Musk warned that switching off the satellite network would have immediate consequences for Kyiv’s military.“If we were to turn off Starlink, the entire Ukrainian front would collapse immediately,” he said, describing SpaceX’s contribution as “incredibly supportive of Ukraine”.
Musk defends restrictions on Ukraine’s Starlink use
His remarks came amid a dispute over restrictions on Ukraine’s access to SpaceX’s satellite communications systems, which have become critical to its drone warfare capabilities against Russia.Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy had complained that restrictions on satellite connectivity were affecting military operations, particularly the use of drones and efforts to intercept Russian attacks.During the interview, journalist Andrew Ross Sorkin asked Musk about Zelenskyy’s claims that Starshield, the military-grade satellite communications system controlled by the US government, had been affected.Musk rejected the Ukrainian president’s account, saying he was referring to the commercial Starlink network rather than Starshield.“That’s false. I don’t want to blow your mind, but Zelenskyy is not always truthful,” Musk said.He also accused the Ukrainian president of misrepresenting Kyiv’s request. “He’s lying, and what he is actually saying is he wants to use Starlink for military, offensive military operations,” Musk said.The SpaceX chief insisted that Starlink was designed as a civilian communications service and should not be used for offensive drone strikes. “Starlink is a civilian system. It is not meant to be used for offensive drone strikes that kill people,” he said, adding that such operations should use Starshield, which is controlled by the US government.Musk said he did not want to be personally responsible for decisions that could result in people being killed.“Do not ask me as a private individual to make kill decisions that sometimes result in the loss of innocent lives, not just soldiers. That is not my position to do,” he said.He also said SpaceX had imposed a speed restriction on Starlink terminals, comparing it to Ukraine’s highway speed limit of approximately 80 miles per hour (129 kmph). The restriction was intended to prevent the commercial network from being used for offensive military operations, he argued.
Musk calls for empathy for Russian soldiers
The billionaire also made controversial remarks about the human cost of the war, urging people to show sympathy for Russian soldiers as well as Ukrainian troops. e argued that Russian soldiers were being conscripted and forced to fight, saying that thousands of young men were being sent to die without any meaningful change in territorial boundaries.“You should have empathy not just for the Ukrainian boys who are dying, but also for the Russian ones because they are conscripted and forced to go to that line,” he said.Musk criticized what he described as a tendency to view Ukraine as entirely good and Russia as entirely bad, arguing that people had become too accepting of violence against Russian soldiers.He acknowledged that Russia was the aggressor in the invasion but also repeated his controversial claim that the US had helped orchestrate the overthrow of Ukraine’s former pro-Russian president Viktor Yanukovych. “It is true that we Americans staged a coup to overthrow the democratically elected pro-Russian president of Ukraine,” he claimed, referring to the 2014 political upheaval that led to Yanukovych fleeing the country.Musk denied that his comments amounted to support for Moscow, pointing to SpaceX’s role in reducing Russia’s access to commercial space launches.
