TVS is not Venu Srinivasan’s ‘personal asset or fiefdom,’ cannot act unilaterally: Lakshmi Venu’s lawyer


TVS is not Venu Srinivasan’s personal asset or “fiefdom”, and he cannot take unilateral decisions on the distribution of ancestral family properties, senior advocate Aryama Sundaram, representing Lakshmi Venu, said on Monday, as the dispute over the partition of the TVS family assets intensifies.

These are certainly not his personal assets or fiefdom.ARYAMA SUNDARAM, SENIOR ADVOCATE

He further told CNBC-TV18, “in Hindu law, it is very clear that properties that have come down as ancestral properties carry what is called a coparcenary interest, which is a joint interest in those properties. It is not open to a person, even if he is the eldest and can be the karta or manager, to divest any of the other coparceners of their shares. So it cannot be his unilateral decision.”

Lakshmi Venu has issued a legal notice to her father, Venu Srinivasan, seeking partition of family assets, invoking her rights as a daughter under the Hindu Succession Act. The notice follows unsuccessful efforts to reach an amicable settlement. The matter has not yet reached court.

Read more: ‘No room for patriarchy in progressive India’: Lakshmi Venu serves partition notice on father Venu Srinivasan

The dispute centres on the interpretation of a family MoU signed in 2024. In an earlier statement in October, Venu Srinivasan had said the separation between his children was about both ownership and control, with Lakshmi Venu given the responsibility of taking forward Sundaram-Clayton and Sudarshan Venu assigned TVS Motor Company and TVS Holdings. He had maintained that both children were given a fair share and that the arrangement was arrived at transparently, after consultation with the family.

Under the MoU, Sudarshan was designated to lead TVS Motor Company and TVS Holdings, while Lakshmi was to lead Sundaram-Clayton. Mallika Srinivasan was designated to lead Tractors and Farm Equipment.

Sundaram said the dispute concerns assets that came to the Venu Srinivasan branch as part of an earlier arrangement within the larger TVS family. While Venu Srinivasan, as head of the branch, could manage and oversee the assets, their distribution among family members had to be equitable.

Read more: TVS Group Succession: ‘No ownership settlement in place,’ claim Lakshmi Venu & Mallika Srinivasan

“There were assets belonging to this family pursuant to the larger family arrangement in the TVS family, which fell to the share of this particular branch,” he said. “However, when it comes to the distribution of assets, that has to be done equitably and equally amongst all the coparceners. It cannot be done in a manner that is completely one-sided or unequal.”

Sundaram alleged that more than 90% of the joint assets appeared to be intended for Venu Srinivasan’s son, Sudarshan Venu.

I don’t think anybody would say that a 90:10 or 95:5 split is equal or equitable.ARYAMA SUNDARAM, SENIOR ADVOCATE

He clarified that the partition being sought was not limited to Venu Srinivasan’s personal holdings but covered the assets of his branch of the larger TVS family, including TVS Holdings and TVS Motor Company. He said an independent valuation would be necessary before any distribution could be determined.

“I’m not willing to put forward back-of-the-envelope calculations… There has to be a valuation by an expert valuer, without which you cannot carry out such a partition at all,” Sundaram said.

Family MoU did not settle asset partition, says lawyer

Responding to claims that a memorandum of understanding (MoU) had already settled the family’s arrangements, Sundaram said the document did not provide for a partition or transfer of ownership of assets.

“The MOU only deals with certain specific issues, as I said, such as brand names, trademarks, non-compete arrangements and management issues relating to who can manage what. It nowhere provides for a division of any assets or a transfer of ownership of any assets,” he said.

He added that there had been no valuation of the assets that came to the Venu Srinivasan branch, questioning how a final settlement could have been reached without one.

Daughters have equal rights in ancestral property

Sundaram said the Hindu Succession Act recognises daughters as coparceners with rights equal to those of male heirs in ancestral property. The 2005 amendment to the Act gave daughters equal rights by birth, he said, leaving no basis for a son to receive a larger share simply because he is male.

“Today, as the law stands, and as it has stood for more than two decades, women have equal shares as coparceners in ancestral coparcenary property, just as men do. They are equal sharers in the property,” he said.

He also drew a distinction between managing a business or asset and owning it, arguing that a family member’s role in running a company does not determine their ownership rights.

Sundaram said Lakshmi Venu had earlier relied on her father’s role as karta and his fiduciary responsibilities, but disclosures about the proposed distribution of beneficial interests had led her to seek a formal partition.

While he said the family still hoped to resolve the dispute without court intervention, he warned that legal action could follow if an agreement could not be reached. “Nobody wants this matter to go to court,” he said, adding that efforts to settle it amicably had been made.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *