The recent rally in India’s benchmark indices has not translated into gains across investor portfolios, reflecting a shift in market leadership as large-cap stocks regain ground after a prolonged period of outperformance by small- and mid-caps.
Over the past 45 days, heavyweight stocks such as HDFC Bank and Reliance Industries have driven the headline indices higher, even as broader portfolios have struggled to keep pace. This is in contrast to the earlier part of the year, when small- and mid-cap stocks did much of the heavy lifting despite weakness in benchmark indices.
Pramod Gubbi, Co-Founder of Marcellus Investment Managers, attributes this divergence partly to the changing valuation equation between large-caps and smaller companies. The valuation gap, which had widened over time, has started narrowing, supported by catalysts such as US elections, the unwinding of the AI trade and the return of foreign money.
However, Gubbi believes the gap remains wide enough to create opportunities for investors who focus on individual companies rather than follow broader market trends.
Why large-caps are regaining ground
The recent change in market leadership follows a prolonged period in which small- and mid-cap stocks outperformed their larger peers, while large-cap valuations continued to widen relative to the broader market.
As large-cap stocks have regained momentum, the valuation gap between the two segments has begun to narrow. This has also influenced the performance of benchmark indices, which can rise sharply when heavyweight constituents rally even if gains are not spread across the wider market.
For Gubbi, the current environment offers opportunities for bottom-up stock picking, with pockets of value and growth emerging across market capitalisations and industries.
“We’ve always remained bottom-up, and we see this market as being very ripe for bottom-up stock picking,” he said in an interview with CNBC-TV18.
Why investors need exposure to both growth and value
One of the challenges in the current market is that attractive valuations and strong growth prospects are not necessarily found in the same companies.
Businesses offering greater visibility on growth may command higher valuations, while stocks that have corrected and appear attractively valued may not have the same growth potential. Gubbi believes investors need a combination of both rather than positioning their portfolios entirely towards either category.
He also pointed out that investment factors such as quality, growth and value go through their own cycles. Since it is difficult to predict which factor will outperform at any given time, relying on a single investment approach can leave portfolios exposed when market preferences change.
At Marcellus, quality remains a key consideration. Gubbi said quality stocks had become cheaper relative to most other investment factors after a prolonged period, creating opportunities across market capitalisations and industries.
Three sectors where Marcellus sees investment opportunities
While Marcellus follows a relatively low-churn investment approach, Gubbi said the fund manager continues to look for opportunities to increase exposure to existing investments when valuation gaps emerge or its conviction strengthens.
He identified financials, healthcare and manufacturing exports as three areas where the investment case is gaining strength.
Financials: The sector is benefiting from sustained credit growth without much deterioration in credit quality. Gubbi said financials had remained relatively attractively valued, making them one of the pockets where Marcellus sees opportunities.
Healthcare: Marcellus is reinforcing its conviction in healthcare, although Gubbi acknowledged that the sector is not particularly cheap. The attraction lies in the visibility of growth and the range of opportunities across hospitals, diagnostics, pharmaceuticals, active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) and contract development and manufacturing organisations (CDMOs).
Manufacturing exports: Gubbi sees growing opportunities in manufacturing exports, supported by improving order books across several subsectors. While rupee depreciation has provided some support, he believes the stabilisation of the currency and the onset of a few free trade agreements (FTAs) could create further opportunities.
However, he cautioned that finding value in this segment is not easy. Marcellus is willing to pay fair multiples for businesses with visible growth prospects but remains wary of paying excessive valuations.
Why even fundamentally strong stocks can correct sharply
The recent pressure on some pharmaceutical stocks, including names that had outperformed during the broader market’s weaker phase, highlights the risks of investing in companies without paying sufficient attention to their valuations.
Responding to a question on how investors should approach news of promoter share sales in fundamentally strong companies, Gubbi said the focus should remain on the underlying business. However, he cautioned that even companies with strong fundamentals, quality management teams and long-term growth prospects can witness sharp corrections when their valuations become stretched.
News of promoter selling or other developments can give investors a reason to book profits, accelerating a stock’s decline. In such situations, the quality of the business alone may not protect its share price.
“There’s a price to all of this, and hence it’s a reminder to all of us that entry-level valuations are very, very important,” he said.
Gubbi also stressed the importance of portfolio rebalancing after sharp rallies. Investors need to review their position sizes to ensure that exposure to individual stocks does not create undue valuation risks.
The changing market leadership and the divergence between benchmark indices and broader portfolios underline the importance of looking beyond headline index performance. For Gubbi, identifying quality businesses, balancing growth and value opportunities, and maintaining discipline on entry valuations remain central to navigating the market.
Why benchmark indices are rallying while investor portfolios lag, according to Pramod Gubbi
